The Matildas star plays for Manchester CIty.
Penrith Panthers CEO Brian Fletcher has come under scrutiny for a comment he made about football star Mary Fowler, which has been perceived by some as disrespectful. The comment was made during an interview when Fletcher was asked about Nathan Cleary’s future at the Panthers, and he jokingly suggested bringing Fowler back to Australia to help keep Cleary in Penrith. Fowler, who plays for Manchester City, has been romantically linked to Cleary, which has fueled speculation about his potential move to the English Super League.
Fletcher clarified that his comment was meant to be light-hearted and emphasized that both Nathan Cleary and his father, Ivan, are signed with the Panthers until 2027. He reiterated that his goal is to keep both Clearys at the club for as long as possible. Despite his intentions, the joke has drawn criticism, with some seeing it as inappropriate, particularly given the high regard in which Fowler is held as a top female athlete.
The incident highlights the delicate nature of public comments, even those made in jest, especially when they involve high-profile individuals and their personal relationships.
Brian Fletcher’s comment about Mary Fowler has stirred some discomfort, primarily because of Fowler’s rising football career in Europe, where she plays for Manchester City and is already earning significant recognition and financial rewards. The suggestion that Fowler should return to Australia to potentially benefit Nathan Cleary’s future was met with criticism, particularly as it downplays her accomplishments and professional trajectory.
Fletcher later clarified that he had no intention of interfering in Fowler and Cleary’s personal relationship, stating that any decision about where Fowler plays is entirely up to her and Nathan. He added that if she did choose to return home, it would quell speculation, but reiterated that it was not his place to influence such matters.
The controversy has sparked debate, with football commentator Simon Hill defending Fletcher by suggesting the remark was likely intended as a joke. Hill emphasized that it would be disrespectful to expect Fowler, a star in her own right and a key figure for the Matildas, to leave her successful career in Europe just for Cleary’s convenience. Hill also highlighted Fowler’s future earning potential, stating that she is poised to become a leading figure in women’s football, potentially out-earning Cleary in the years to come.
Nathan Cleary, a four-time NRL premiership winner, has since dismissed speculation about a move to the English Super League, firmly stating that he has no plans to relocate anytime soon. Cleary is contracted with the Penrith Panthers until 2027, and the club is expected to work on extending his deal even further.