It’s widely recognized that football opinions can vary greatly, adding to the excitement of following the game. However, the latest take on Newcastle United’s potential major signing is particularly perplexing and requires a considerable amount of mental gymnastics to understand.
While it’s unlikely that many Newcastle fans are indifferent to the prospect of Marc Guehi joining the club, there might be a few. As it stands, Newcastle is set to sign one of England’s top central defenders for approximately £65 million.
Although this is a significant sum, Guehi’s potential impact is considerable. His performance for England at Euro 2024 demonstrated his quality, suggesting he would seamlessly integrate into Newcastle’s defense—though, of course, not everyone might share this view.
Don Hutchison, a former Sunderland player and Newcastle supporter, has expressed skepticism about the club’s pursuit of Marc Guehi. Speaking on ESPN Sports, Hutchison said:
“Not really.
“Not because the kid is not a good player. They signed Lloyd Kelly on a free transfer, and they’ve got Sven Botman and Fabian Schar. That’s a lot of money to spend on what is potentially a good player, but he might not get in the team.”
Hutchison doubts that Marc Guehi would secure a starting spot ahead of Sven Botman and Fabian Schar, despite the potential cost. He questioned the wisdom of spending such a significant amount on Guehi, suggesting the funds could be better used elsewhere.
Presenter Dan Thomas argued that a major investment like Guehi would likely ensure a starting role, but Hutchison remained unconvinced.
However, it’s possible Hutchison might reconsider his stance if Guehi and Botman establish a formidable partnership in defense once Botman returns to full fitness later in the season.